Zeffy vs Givebutter
Zeffy offers one product at $0 and covers card fees through optional donor tips. Givebutter also has a free CRM with unlimited contacts, then sells Plus from $29 a month, priced by contact count. Nonprofits that want no paid tier at all lean toward Zeffy; those that want AI tools and paid extras lean toward Givebutter.
Side by side
| What it is | Free fundraising software and CRM funded by donor tips | Free fundraising platform with a built-in CRM |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Very small nonprofits and volunteer-run groups | Teams that fundraise mostly online |
| Headquarters | Canada | United States |
| Pricing model | Free (donor tips) | Free plus tiered by contacts |
| Pricing | Free: Zeffy states every feature costs $0 and relies on optional contributions donors add at checkout. | Free CRM with unlimited contacts; Plus starts at $29 per month, scaled by contact count, and a flat 3% platform fee applies if donor tips are disabled. |
| Free option | Free plan | Free plan |
| List price as listed on November 15, 2026 | $0 (one product, no paid plan; fees funded by optional donor tips) | Free plan at $0; Plus from $29 per month billed annually (250 or fewer contacts) |
| Place in our donor management software ranking | #13 of 13 | #3 of 13 |
| Website | zeffy.com | givebutter.com |
Both are reviewed in full in Best Donor Management Software in 2026. Vendors can pay for more visibility, and commercial relationships can affect which products we feature and how prominently. Placement disclosure.
Which one to choose
Choose Zeffy if
you want a single free product with no paid tier to outgrow, and you are comfortable with fees being funded by optional donor tips.
Zeffy, #13 in the ranking · Visit Zeffy →
Choose Givebutter if
you want a free CRM now with a paid upgrade for workflows, texting and QuickBooks Online later, plus built-in AI for campaigns and donor insights.
Givebutter, #3 in the ranking · Visit Givebutter →
Where they differ
Whether a paid tier exists at all
Zeffy's pricing page says it costs $0, is not a free tier or a trial, and has no paid plan above it, no per-user cost and no contract. Givebutter's Free plan is also $0 forever with unlimited users and contacts, but Plus sits above it from $29 a month. If never meeting an upgrade prompt matters most, Zeffy's model is simpler.
Edge: Zeffy
How the card fees get paid
Both lean on optional donor tips. Zeffy says it covers credit card and transaction fees and that on average 2 of 3 donors tip. Givebutter charges 0% platform and processing fees with tips on, but with tips off it applies a flat 3% platform fee plus processor rates of 2.9% + 30 cents. Zeffy describes no such fallback on its pricing page, though we could not read its terms.
Edge: Zeffy
What the paid upgrade adds
Givebutter Plus adds automated workflows, task management, reporting, texting, video messages, discounted direct mail, QuickBooks Online and priority phone support, starting at $29 a month for up to 250 contacts and rising with contact count. Zeffy lists no add-on tier, so nothing equivalent can be bought. A team that wants these extras has to go to Givebutter. The catch is that contact-based pricing grows with your list.
Edge: Givebutter
AI and data-access features
Givebutter lists Givebutter Magic, built-in AI for campaigns, goals and donor insights, and connectors that give ChatGPT, Claude and other AI tools access to Givebutter data. The Zeffy pricing page we opened mentions no AI features, which tells us little about the rest of its product. On what is verified, Givebutter is the one with AI. We compare only what we could open.
Edge: Givebutter
Reporting and export evidence
Givebutter's free feature list names financial reports, payout reconciliations and data exports. Zeffy describes CRM and donor management as included at no cost, but we could not verify its export options or read its terms and privacy pages, which returned errors when we tried. The honest result is a tie on paper, with the Zeffy side unconfirmed. Check both before migrating donor records.
Edge: even
Tally: Zeffy 2, Givebutter 2, even 1.
When neither fits
Neither suits a nonprofit that needs a long-established donor stewardship system with written-communication coaching. Bloomerang is built around stewardship, and Donorbox is a simpler fit for teams that only need card donations on their own forms.
See Bloomerang and Donorbox among the 13 products in Best Donor Management Software in 2026.
Questions and answers
Is Zeffy really free?
Zeffy says it costs $0 on its pricing page, with no paid plan, no per-user cost, no trial and no contract. It says it covers card and transaction fees and relies on optional donor tips, with on average 2 of 3 donors tipping.
Is Givebutter free for nonprofits?
Givebutter has a Free plan at $0 per month with unlimited users, contacts, email blasts and fundraising campaigns. Paid Plus starts at $29 per month for up to 250 contacts when billed annually, and a 30-day commitment-free test is offered.
What fees does Givebutter charge?
With donor tips on, Givebutter charges 0% platform fee and 0% processing fee. With tips off, it charges a flat 3% platform fee plus standard processor rates shown as 2.9% + 30 cents per transaction.
Does Givebutter have AI features?
Yes, Givebutter lists Givebutter Magic for campaigns, goals and donor insights. It also offers AI connectors that give ChatGPT, Claude and other AI tools access to your Givebutter data. Zeffy's pricing page does not mention AI features.
How does Givebutter Plus pricing scale?
Plus pricing depends on contact count. Billed annually it shows $29 per month for 250 or fewer contacts, $79 for 1,000 and $129 for 2,500, with higher tiers marked Talk to sales.
Sources
Prices, plan limits and product facts on this page were checked against the vendors' own pages on November 15, 2026. Vendors change both without notice, so treat the figures as of that date.
- Givebutter pricing page: Free and Plus prices, fee model with and without tips, 30-day test, Givebutter Magic AI and the free feature list
- Givebutter about page: Remote team spread across 25 states and 8 countries
- Givebutter terms: Givebutter, Inc. as the contracting company, subscription billing and arbitration wording
- Givebutter privacy policy: Processing of personal information in the United States and access or deletion requests
- Zeffy pricing page: Zeffy at $0, optional donor tips, no trial, no paid plan and the one-plan wording
- Donorbox pricing page: Donorbox listed as an alternative for card donation forms
- Donorbox pricing blog post: Opened as background on Donorbox; no figure from it is used
- Bloomerang pricing page: Bloomerang listed as an alternative for donor stewardship and communications